Rated 2 out of
Bring back the old formula!I've been using this eyeliner for 10 years. I loved everything about it, one of the reasons being how easy it is to use. Although it wasn't waterproof it lasted for more than 24 hours, very impressing...until now! I don't know what you did, but you definitely changed the formula. It doesn't last at all, at the end of the day it's gone from my face, smudgy, not a good look at all! The black is not intense as it's used to. After all these years, I started looking for a new eyeliner, because this one is great disappointment. I hope you bring back the old formula one day. I won't be back otherwise. Such a pity. You lost yourself a loyal customer!
Date published: 2018-04-26
Rated 1 out of
Megs 533 from
Ice Black!!!!!!This is a great product but the colors offered just don’t work. I posted on here about a year ago begging you to bring back ice black. I am certainly not alone as if you read through these comments ice black is the color that everyone wants. You referred me to another product and I see you have done that to others as well, but the product is not a liquid eyeliner. It is a pencil. I personally cannot use those as it is impossible to get a really thin line. In the meantime I have wasted lots of money buying other brands. They aren’t the same.PLEASE, Lancôme...LISTEN TO YOUR CUSTOMERS!!
Date published: 2019-10-28
Rated 5 out of
Brilliant ProductThis product is perfect. I will start with the applicator. It is a soft, flexible, sponge type material. It holds enough product to complete one eye and then some. It tapers to a fine point so you can perfectly customize from a fine line to a thick line. You can go from thin to thick without lifting the tip. Just apply more pressure. The pointy tip makes a beautiful tapering cat-eye. The product is smooth, highly pigmented, and smudge-proof. It stays intense and sharp-edged all day. I look forward to doing my eyeliner now! I think it is rather expensive and I hope it lasts for a while, but the price is not a deal breaker as I am so very pleased with it.
Date published: 2011-10-17
Rated 3 out of
Why No Iceblack??Hi! I'm wondering what color I can use to replace the ice black. Are used ice black for 18 years along with my three sisters and two great friends. We all LOVE Ice Black and wonder why you don't offer it anymore? Will you be offering it at all in the future? It is a perfect color for women who are over 50. It is a soft collar and it is in Hance into the eyes. And wonder why you don't offer it anymore? Will you be offering it at all in the future? It is a perfect color for women who are over 50. It is a soft collar and it is in Hance into the eyes. Please let me know if you'll be offering this excellent color again in the future. I loved this product from I loved this product from a long cold. Lancôme. :-)
Date published: 2018-11-10
Rated 5 out of
You can stop reading now and order...If you like liquid eyeliner, you will love this one! If you've never tried, it's the perfect eyeliner to try!
I have tried at least a dozen liquid liners, not to mention gels and pencils over the years, but this has THE best applicator! Plus, the colors are so flattering and it stays on all day! (I use pencil to line my lower lid, and often need to reapply that, but not the top#
I have brown hair and eyes and I'm now trying new-to-me shades other than brown and black #noir). So far, navy and aubergine are favorites, although the lighter blue looks nice, too. Next to try is Forest...like brown, navy and aubergine, I suspect it will look very good with any coloring.
Date published: 2013-04-24
Rated 4 out of
Still WaitingArtliner is still the best eyeliner I've ever used but it's disappointing that after over a year there still aren't any alternatives available to Ice Black. Shimmer colors are still available in this product (Menthe/green, Azur/blue, Cuir/brown, 1967 Moderato/gold) but no softer black/grey options. I had been an Ice Black user for 20+ years and it seems I'm not the only reviewer who feels Nior and Smoke are too harsh for our aging skin tones. The search still continues for replacement outside the Lancôme family.
Date published: 2018-11-27
Rated 5 out of
Beautiful, lasting liner--I own the black, a brown, and the purple color. The purple works very well with my brown eyes. It is very dark, but has a hint of purple that brings my eyes out. The black is deep and the brown is okay. The most amazing thing about these liners is the fact that they can stay on so well. I am able to wipe my eyes if I need to and the liner doesn't smudge. Even sample swatch I put on my hand in the store stuck on for hours regardless of trying to get it off several times with only my fingers.
These were also great "starter" liners for me. I am not very good with these eyeliners and I found this to be easy to use and smooth. You can also make a fine line with the tip. I would definitely suggest these to a friend if they were shy about liner.
Date published: 2012-09-01
Rated 5 out of
Mourning the Loss of Ice BlackArtliner is absolutely the best eyeliner! It goes on smoothly, is long wear, and has the perfect sized applicator tip. The product itself is still wonderful; however, after using Ice Black for almost 20 years it’s been stripped from the color selection. It was a perfect shimmering blend of black, brown, and grey and has been the only color that elegantly lined my eyes versus leaving harsh Black or Smoke lines on my pale, aging skin. Unfortunately, the search has begun outside Lancôme for an alternative.