item(s) added to your bag!Checkout
stay don't stray
Rated 1 out of 5 by lolojenelle from What Happened?! I've been using this product for 3 years. I have loved it until now. It was initially great with the pump. Then when the product's application device was changed to a wand, I was somewhat upset. However, it worked okay. Now the pump is back, and it has been quite an experience...a not so pleasant experience. Half of what comes out is some watery liquid, but the worst part is it squirts out product and you never know where it is going to land. Today (and not for the first time) it squirted out and landed on a really nice pair of pants, and now I'm not quite sure if the stain will come out. Please fix this product! It was so great before :(
Date published: 2014-05-18
Rated 1 out of 5 by lollie830 from Please bring back the old packaging! I signed up for an acct just to write this review...this is how upset I am! This was one THE BEST and my MUST HAVE product. After trying all different brands of concealer, I finally find the perfect one. The product lasted a very long time as well. When I finally ran out and purchased a new one, I was extremely disappointed to discover the packaging changed. It does not go on the same and I have to use a lot more to have the same coverage. It only last me a few mos before it ran/dried out. I ended up switching to the Fake Up concealer and it doesn't last throughout the day since it's a lot more oily. PLEASE BRING BACK THE OLD PACKAGING AND FORMULA!!!
Date published: 2014-06-25
Rated 1 out of 5 by Robin39 from Please,Please bring back the ORIGINAL formula! I have purchased the original product for years and have relied on it to cover up many things. It is the one product I would make sure I took with me and always made sure I never ran out. I have very dark circles under my eyes and it covered so well I needed nothing else. And it stayed on all day. It was the most amazing product I have ever used. And then Benefit changed the delivery from pump to wand. I was excited to try it until I saw how watery it is. It is NOT the same formula...it covers nothing! I am so disappointed. For a product to have gone from best to worst is a shock. It is so useless I don't even use it. I will not purchase this ever again unless Benefit goes back to the ORIGINAL formula.
Date published: 2014-09-09
Rated 1 out of 5 by Eskiegirl from Glad I'm not the only one... This used to be the BEST shadow primer, hands down. I could pump exactly the right amount, and the formula was thick and covered well. This stuff used to hold shadow through an hour's worth of cardio with my face dripping in sweat, and it looked like it hadn't even been touched. Ever since the package was redesigned to use the wand instead of the pump, the formula is watery, doesn't cover well, and i'm lucky if i can get through 4hrs sitting at my desk at work without my shadow coming off, let alone through the whole day. This used to be a staple in my makeup kit, and I've recommended it to friends, but unless the formula is reverted to the original, I'm going to have to try to find an alternative.
Date published: 2014-06-22
Rated 1 out of 5 by Lisa61 from Not happy with the applicator I have used stay-put primer for over 3 years and had loved it. The previous product was fantastic. The new version-with the wand is awful. The product is much thinner. Need to use a lot more or eye makeup wears off soon. Previously used a small amount from the pump and it would last all day. The pump product would last me about 8 months. The current product lasts under 4 months. I am getting a lot less for my money. Also the wand carries a great chance of germs and infection. I am not a happy customer and will be looking elsewear for a different product. Please bring back pump!!
Date published: 2014-01-26
Rated 2 out of 5 by Christina79 from This WAS one of my must-have products! I was very loyal to this product, it was one of a few that I HAD to have and I bought it over and over. Sadly, since the switch to the wand container, the product just isn't the same. I was initially glad about the switch, as I always dispensed too much product with the pump. I've been using the new one a few weeks now, and the product is thinner and glossier and doesn't cover and apply nearly as well. (I LOVED this product as a concealer, too.) Please bring back the product in the pump container, I NEED this in my life again! I've had to resort to hoarding the original product from wherever I can find it to hold me over until I can discover a suitable replacement. (or until Benefit brings back the original product, fingers crossed!)
Date published: 2014-05-06
Rated 3 out of 5 by shell0belle from Packaging not quite as expected When I ordered this product, I was expecting the brush applicator so was a little disappointed to see it was a pump! However, I have managed to figure out how to use it so too much doesn't come out and get wasted. It goes on really nicely and actually works! Although I still need to apply concealer over top to reduce my under eye circles, this product is great at preventing my eye-shadow from fading or creasing which is a problem I usually have. My only negative is the pump - it's quite hard to apply and get a good coverage, so I think the applicator which is pictured would be better.
Date published: 2013-02-22
Rated 2 out of 5 by eclaired from New formula is a bummer I have loved this product for years & was surprised to see changes to it the last time I bought it. After using it, I have to agree with the recent reviews - the changes are NOT GOOD. While the new applicator wand doesn't really bother me much, the new formula is the pits!! Stay Don't Stray was the ONLY eye shadow primer that worked all day with my hooded lids. Now, I'm getting creasing mere hours after application. With the older formula, that wouldn't happen unless I wore my makeup for 8+ hours. I will NOT be buying or recommending this product any longer. I WILL start my search for a new, long-lasting primer. Boo :-(
Date published: 2015-08-04