Rated 1 out of
Great but not for waterproof makeupGentle wipe but inefficient to remove waterproof or resistant eyes makeup (ex cream eyeliner or long lasting stila eyeliner).
Returned them despite the great deal.
Wipes are also smaller than the Neutrogena ones that do miracles for waterproof makeup.
Was looking for non scented wipes a bit better for the skin that the Neutrogena with no perfume. The latest irritate my skin around the eyes not because of the formula but because of the material of the wipe